Ep61: Philipp Kristian Diekhöner – The Impact of Foreign Currency on a Managed Fund

Listen on

Apple | Overcast Stitcher | Spotify | Other

Guest profile

Philipp Kristian Diekhöner is a keynote TEDx speaker, global innovation strategist and author of The Trust Economy, published in English (2017), German (2018) and Simplified Chinese (2019). Philipp has spoken at eminent global organizations such as FacebookP&GMicrosoftTurnerMunich ReZillowGlobe TelecomCPA AustraliaGermany’s Federal Ministry for Economics and Energy, the Economist Intelligence Unit and many othersHe’s written for ForbesEsquiree27Marketing Mag and InVision blog plus several industry publications and featured across Springer ProfessionalMen’s FolioMoney FM 89.3 and Your Story. Philipp is also a founding partner of DDX, the awardwinning German innovation house that helps companies innovate the most trusted products and services. In his free time, he’s an avid sailor and yogi.  

 Trust issues are highly relevant to investing

After spending almost a decade working around the world in the sphere of innovation within numerous disciplines, Philipp makes two important observations, that: (1) effecting change is particularly difficult, and (2) trust is essential whenever we are trying to do something interesting or new. In fact, the world changes when trust patterns shift. This is why he says that old technology lingers because it has managed to remain trustedHe added that by the same token, new tech that is actually not very good can still succeed because we have somehow given it our trust. This change, whether good or bad, is very relevant to investing. 

 

“When it comes to financial markets, our trust in the way the world works determines which things change
and which things stay the same.”

Philipp Kristian Diekhöner

 

Summary: Tech influences the way we trust businesses

This episode dives deep into a story about the placing (and misplacing) of trust in todays technologyOur guest Philipp looks back at his investment in a robo-advisor fintech startup in Singapore. He was attracted to its sophisticated digital interface and trusted them to actively manage his portfolio. At closer inspection, he discovered that his investment had taken a big hit due to a currency correction of which he had not been informed.  

Phillip commands a unique perspective on trust, but was led astray based on misplaced trust in the gadgetry and slick delivery of the robo-advisor and its promoters. Despite this disappointment, he nevertheless learned a profound lesson that has paved the way to his development of new methods of research. He warns investors to beware of putting money into a company that provides no absolute proof points” or evidence to back up their claims. And ultimately, to do their homework on what they place their trust in, an essential point to remember when assessing risk. 

 

“With investments, there is always a difference between trustworthy players and trusted players. Some people just choose to be only trusted but not trustworthy. And at the end of the day, from losing a couple of grand worth of money,
I actually realized that I gained a lot of insight into my topic.”

Philipp Kristian Diekhöner

 

Early win with robo-advisor lifts fintech’s appeal  

Philipp had worked with a number of startups also in the Singapore fintech space and one was the robo-advisorsmartly. He knew the people well as he had helped them launch in the city-state as a pioneer of some of the definitely more interesting fintech products. He also invested with them and earned some rewarding returns, all the while feeling that it was all more hip, modern, and relevant to him than investing in a bank or in the markets: “Because we all know that banks incentives are not aligned to yours. His inside knowledge of working in finance for years added to him being shy of dealing with the world of conventional investments, as he knew also what was going on behind the scenes.  

Flush from modest wins and impressed by the tech, Philipp looked at a new robo-advisor company in Singapore with a sleek interface. He had written a lot about digital interfaces and appreciated that people were increasingly putting a lot of trust in them. As did he, injecting a sizeable chunk of money into it thinking that the robo-advisors presented well and that it appeared they would do as good a job as smartly had done.  

Undisclosed forex exposure robs his stake of value

The outfit’s pitch had included that the size of clients’ fees were due to it being “full-service” enterprise and that experts would actively manage his portfolio. But when Philipp actually started looking into its investment framework, it turned out to be mostly a work of fiction. While digging even deeper, he discovered there a major US currency correction had occurred, which can have major implications on any US-dollar-denominated investment. In his case, that meant a loss of around US$7,000), which definitely hurt.  

Management fails to tell clients of present danger

While the robo-advisor had been sold as an actively managed product”, the “managers” neglected to inform customers of the big change in currency values and that they were rebalancing the portfolio in response. Philipp only found out when he realized his investment had slid in a big way. When he challenged management, they just told him to wait. All the promise of an investment that claimed to be sophisticated, tech-driven and active, was in fact neither fair nor trustworthy.  

Big ROI came not in dollars but in insight

Despite his considerable losses, Philipp profited in another way – understanding. He realized he had been caught by placing excessive trust in digital interfaces and the people who create and brag about them and their own expertise. He admitted also that he invested little time or interest in doing his own research, and that all of this had cost him a lot of money.  

Philipps takeaways 

1. Beware of cognitive bias – Philipp admits he suffered from a number of biasesin the illusory correlation between successful investment in one start-up robo-advisor (with which he had worked with, had close knowledge of management, who were trustworthy, and ran using a sound investment framework), and another foray with a start-up robo-advisor (which had an attractive digital interface, was very ambitious, had plenty of fundingbut completely lacked a sound investment framework)What’s more, the second target didn’t care about investors money, failed to communicate the fatal flaw of exposure to currency fluctuations and had no solid proof points” to back up the claimed benefits of their product.   

2. Do due diligence and exercise caution – And especially avoid doing business with companies that tender fake reviews. After doing the research that Philipp admits he should have done prior to investing, Philipp also discovered that the robo-advisor company was asking its employees to post favorable reviews online. His initial hypothesis for this company was very positive due to prior wins with a similar company, which was a clear case of misplaced trust and a type of cognitive bias (see Takeaway 1.).  

3. The dark side of digital interfaces is that they can elicit excessive trust – Technology is actually taking trust away from physical interactions and digitizing it, and this has positive and negative implications. 

 

“Trust is kind of like The Force … if you’re a Star Wars fan),  it can be used for good and can it be used for bad.”

Philipp Kristian Diekhöner

 

Andrews Takeaways

1. Trust is a fundamental part of motivating change, whether positive or negative – If we lose trust in something, that causes a big change too.

2. Understand what is behind the presentation – Most companies have impressive presentations these days, but investors must make companies prove the methodology behind the slick exterior of an investment program.

3. Demand to know a target companys risk management plan – As every company presents well, it is more important to know all the potential risks and what plans the company has in place to manage them in the future. Investors should not just accept a boilerplate warning about certain risks. They should ask: “Well what are you going to do about it?” 

 

“Focus not so much on the return, but focus on the risk and what have they done in the past and
what would they do if this happened?”

Andrew Stotz

 

4. Beware of falling for misplaced trust – We are very accepting of all the apps being presented as part of the interface with our personal phones that we misplace trust and think that we can trust what is behind the app.  

Actions to avoid making the same mistakes

A. Do your own research  If an investment opportunity seems too good to be true, it probably is! In a world where everything is served up to us minute to minute, no one seems to want to actually do the research. 

B. Ask around  If you ask people who know about investing, you can arrive at a consensus on what an investment target is truly like, especially whether it is legitimate or not. But you do have to make that effort. You don’t really have to read 15,000 pages of theory. 

C. If you want to get involved in high-risk investing, start with small batches – The small batch of money might give you a high return, but you might risk losing a large amount. So, put the bulk of your money in conservative and relatively safer investments. That’s a safer method until a company proves itself.  

 

“High risk is not just about a high return, high risk is also about investing in somebody that you don’t know.”

Philipp Kristian Diekhöner

 

Philipp’s final words: I actually love talking about my worst investment because it taught me a lot and I actually feel by having gone through that … (it) really got me thinking in a new form about my own research. 

  • He gave a different and refreshing insight on trust and explains how digitizing this trust has positive and negative implications. 
  • He realized that one should look at a company on how well it is building trust and talked about the difference between trustworthy and trusted players. 

Andrews final words: I like the idea of what we would call position size, and you build a small position into something and this is a risk management tool.” 

Read Philipps book:

Andrew’s books

Andrew’s online programs

Connect with Philipp Kristian Diekhöner:

Connect with Andrew Stotz:

Regulatory authority mentioned

About the author, Andrew

Dr. Andrew Stotz, CFA is the CEO of A. Stotz Investment Research, a company that provides institutional and high net worth investors with ready-to-invest stock portfolios that aim to beat the benchmark through superior stock selection.

Leave a Comment